If you have a gas fireplace with a stone surround and want a traditional, wood-burning brick fireplace in Youngstown, OH, it’s a project that touches structure, safety, and local climate concerns. Homeowners choose this conversion to regain a classic look, improve heating feel, or restore an older home’s character—but the job is more than ripping out the gas logs and setting new brick. This guide explains the scope, key variables that affect price, expected timing, and the questions to ask your masonry contractor.

What the job typically involves

1. Assessment and planning: A qualified mason inspects the existing fireplace, flue, hearth, and chimney to determine whether the current structure can serve a wood-burning fire. Many gas setups have different clearances, liners, or venting that don’t meet code for wood fireplaces. The inspector checks for creosote buildup, chimney soundness, and whether the hearth needs enlarging or reinforcement.

2. Removing the gas components and surround: The gas logs, burner, and associated gas line are safely disconnected by a licensed plumber or gas technician. The stone surround and any non-masonry facing are removed to expose the substrate. If you hire a contractor to manage the whole job, they will coordinate gas shutoff and permits.

3. Chimney and flue work: Wood-burning fires require a properly sized chimney and a safe, code-compliant flue lining. That may mean relining an existing chimney, repairing cracked flue tiles, rebuilding the chimney stack, or installing a stainless-steel liner. If the existing chimney was sized only for gas, upsizing or relining is common.

4. Building the brick firebox and surround: Brick masonry for the firebox and visible surround uses refractory bricks and mortar rated for high heat where needed; the visible facing can be standard brick chosen for aesthetic match. The hearth extension, smoke shelf, and lintel or arch are constructed to code.

5. Flashing, cap, and finishing: Exterior repairs include flashing and a new chimney cap if needed. Interior finishing—tuckpointing, sealing, and cleaning—completes the look.

Factors that most affect price

- Chimney condition and flue work: If the chimney requires rebuilding, relining, or structural repair, that can be the largest single cost. A simple relining is less expensive than rebuilding a damaged stack.

- Need to enlarge or reinforce the hearth/firebox: Some conversions require expanding the hearth or installing new supports—especially if the floor is not solid or the opening changes size.

- Type of brick and finish: Full-thickness brick facing costs more than thin-brick veneer. Refractory firebrick in the firebox is required and more expensive than standard decorative brick.

- Complexity of demo and disposal: Removing stone surrounds can be labor-intensive, especially if the stone is anchored into structural elements. Hauling and disposal add to the budget.

- Permits and inspections: Municipal permitting, required inspections, and coordination with licensed gas or HVAC contractors add time and cost but are necessary for safety and resale value.

- Hidden conditions: Old chimneys often conceal rot, damaged framing, or corroded metal. Discovering these during work increases cost.

Typical price ranges (ballpark) for Youngstown area

Every job is unique. As a rough guide: converting a basic gas fireplace to a code-compliant wood-burning firebox with a new brick surround and minor flue work could start in the low thousands. If the chimney needs relining or moderate repair, expect mid-range costs. Extensive chimney rebuilding, structural repairs, or custom brickwork can push the project into the higher range. Request a written estimate that itemizes chimney work, hearth/firebox construction, materials, and disposal so you can compare bids.

Realistic timeline

- Inspection and permit stage: 1–2 weeks (depends on permit office and scheduling).

- Demo and site prep: 1–3 days.

- Chimney/flue repairs or relining: 1–7 days depending on complexity.

- Masonry construction (firebox, surround, hearth): 3–10 days depending on size and design.

- Finishing, inspections, and cleanup: 1–3 days.

Overall, expect 1–3 weeks for most straightforward conversions, and 3–6 weeks when significant chimney rebuilding, structural work, or permit delays occur.

Safety and code considerations

- Never use a wood fire in a chimney sized or lined only for gas. That risks smoke backflow, overheating, and chimney fires.

- A properly installed chimney cap, crown, and flashing protect the masonry from Youngstown’s freeze-thaw cycles and winter precipitation.

- Local building codes may require a licensed mason, inspections, and a chimney reliner rated for wood-burning appliances.

Questions to ask your contractor

- Do you inspect the chimney and provide a written recommendation before work begins?

- Will you coordinate gas disconnection with a licensed plumber and handle permits/inspections?

- Do you use refractory brick and mortar in the firebox and code-approved liners for wood-burning chimneys?

- Can you provide itemized estimates showing chimney work, hearth construction, brick facing, and disposal?

- Do you offer references or photos of similar conversions completed in the area?

Preparing for the job

Clear the room and protect finishes; expect some dust and vibration. If you have pets or items sensitive to dust, move them away. Ask the contractor for a brief schedule so you know when noisy or messy steps occur.

Bottom line

Converting a gas fireplace to a wood-burning brick fireplace in Youngstown is a rewarding upgrade when done right: it restores traditional ambiance but requires careful chimney evaluation, proper liners and refractory materials, and attention to code. Get a professional inspection, an itemized estimate, and a realistic schedule before you commit. Superior Masonry Youngstown can evaluate your fireplace, explain options for brick vs. thin veneer, and provide a clear, written plan tailored to your home and budget.